On Paper✳

PIECE 13The conditionsLiving document

The question

Are planning rules making homes too dear to build?

Short answer:Not the charges. Planning contributions and connections are 4% of a new apartment’s cost. When the 2025 rules were loosened, a real Dublin block got €36k cheaper per home, mostly by building smaller homes.

Why it matters:When you hear “just scrap the rules”, the saving is smaller than it sounds.

Piece8 min read3 chaptersupdated October 2026every figure traceable to a named table

Every condition attached to a new home is defended on its own terms: a lift here, a second stairwell there, a car space, a balcony, a minimum floor area. Each one is reasonable. Nobody has had to defend the total, because nobody has added it up.

The surveyors come closest. Their costing of a new two-bed apartment runs to €553,203, line by line, and the line for the State's planning charges is one of the smallest on the page. Then, in 2025, the rules were loosened, and they costed what that did to a real building.

The short version
4%

Of a new two-bed apartment's cost is planning contributions and utility connections: €20,400. Derived from the SCSI's own lines.

€36k

Cheaper to deliver, per home, when a real Dublin block was redesigned under the looser 2025 rules. But it earned €23k less per home.

-3%

The margin afterwards, up from -5%. Still a loss without other help.

The planning charges people point at are small. The design rules matter more, but loosening them saved less than the argument suggests, because most of the saving came from building smaller homes.

Your voice — 150 words, at the top

A building you know that took years to get from permission to keys — or a requirement you have seen argued over at a council meeting.

  • Grounds the 'conditions' in a place before the costing.

One · The stack, line by linea two-bed apartment

Nine lines add up to a new two-bed apartment. Planning charges are among the smallest.

The surveyors' costing, as printed, for a five-to-eight-storey scheme at the lower end of the range.

What a new two-bed apartment costs to deliver, line by line

Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland, 2025: Category 2, lower range, including VAT on the sale.

How to read thisEach bar is one line of the cost. The highlighted line is the one people usually mean by 'planning costs'.

Construction · €284,000 · 51%
Margin and risk · €64,710 · 12%
VAT on the sale · €57,093 · 10%
Site purchase · €50,000 · 9%
Finance · €31,000 · 6%
Professional fees · €24,000 · 4%
Development contributions and connections · €20,400 · 4%
Selling costs · €12,000 · 2%
Contingency · €10,000 · 2%

SCSI, The Real Costs of New Apartment Delivery 2025, Figure 3. Percentages are ours, from the printed lines. Derived.

The numbers behind this chartTable & CSV
Line€Share (%)
Construction284,00051.3
Site purchase50,0009.0
Development contributions and connections20,4003.7
Professional fees24,0004.3
Selling costs12,0002.2
Finance31,0005.6
Contingency10,0001.8
Margin and risk64,71011.7
VAT on the sale57,09310.3

Total €553,203 is the sum of the printed lines. Tier 2.

Download CSV

Planning contributions, water and wastewater connections, fire and access certificates and defects insurance together come to €20,400, 3.7% of the cost. VAT on the sale is €57,093.

The margin line is a target, not a profit. The €64,710 is the 15% return the surveyors say a builder needs before going ahead. At the price this apartment would actually sell for, €480,000, their own appendix shows a loss: €8,493, or 2%.

A gap in the source. These nine lines add up to €553,203. The same report's headline for this apartment is €541,000. That is €12,203 apart, too much to be rounding, and the report does not explain it. We chart the lines, because the percentages printed beside them match their sum. If the SCSI explains the difference, this page will be corrected.

Houses look the same. For a three-bed semi in the Dublin area the surveyors' 2023 costing is €461,437. The council's planning levy is €11,900, 2.6% (derived), and water, gas and electricity connections another €6,745. In the Midlands the levy was €3,200.

Two · What the rules costthe 2025 loosening

When the rules were loosened, a real building got cheaper per home. Mostly because the homes got smaller.

In July 2025 the State relaxed its apartment standards. The surveyors took a 48-home block in south Dublin and redrew it under the new rules.

What changed in the rules: a studio can now be 32 square metres. Only a quarter of apartments need windows on two sides, where it used to be a third or a half. There is no longer a limit on how many homes on each floor share a lift and stairs. Developers no longer have to cap studios and one-beds.

In the surveyors' test, the same building, with the same outline, went from 48 homes to 54: seven studios replaced three three-bed homes, and two more two-beds were added.

What the 2025 rules saved, per home, in one Dublin block

A 48-home, six-storey scheme redrawn under the July 2025 guidelines. Build-to-sell, per home.

How to read thisEach bar is how much one line of the cost fell, per home, after the redesign.

Construction · −€22k
Site purchase · −€6k
Finance · −€4k
Professional fees · −€2k
Selling costs · −€1k
Contingency · −€1k
Contributions and connections · no change

SCSI, The Real Costs of New Apartment Delivery 2025, Part II, Table 10. Rounded to €1,000 by the SCSI; the lines do not always add to its total.

The numbers behind this chartTable & CSV
LineChange per home (€)
Construction-22,000
Site purchase-6,000
Finance-4,000
Professional fees-2,000
Selling costs-1,000
Contingency-1,000
Contributions and connections0
Total, before VAT and margin-36,000
Average sale revenue-23,000

As printed. Tier 2.

Download CSV

The cost per home fell by €36,000, from €468,000 to €433,000. But the average home now sold for €23,000 less, because more of them were studios. The surveyors say so: the saving was "driven by the change in mix", not necessarily by homes costing less to build.

The margin went from -5% to -3%. Better, and still a loss. The surveyors expect more from a building designed under the new rules from scratch, rather than redrawn.

The State's own guidelines say car parking "can add significant cost". They do not say how much. And the rules themselves are in doubt: a judicial review was lodged in October 2025, and the Government has said it will withdraw and replace them.

Objection, from a builder

"The charges are not the point. It is the standards. Every rule adds cost, and together they make apartments unviable outside the biggest cities."

Partly right. The standards cost more than the charges, and the one costed test shows that loosening them helped.

But it helped by 2 points, and mostly by building smaller homes that sell for less. On the surveyors' own figures, the standards are one cost among several, not the whole story. And one building is not a country: the State sets the standards, so it should publish what they cost.

Is it the objectors, then? The planning board loses or concedes 56% of judicial reviews.Precedent →

Three · What would move itnow what

Cost the rules the way the rules cost everyone else.

Two changes, neither of which lowers a standard by itself.

1
Publish a costed impact for every design standardThe 2025 guidelines say parking adds significant cost and give no figure. Each new or revised standard should come with what it adds to a typical home.
2
Report the stack every yearThe SCSI does this as a professional body, from a sample. The State could do it from its own schemes, line by line, every year.
About the data

Two totals in one report. The SCSI's lines for this apartment sum to €553,203; its headline figure is €541,000. We chart the lines, whose printed percentages match their sum.

A target margin. The margin line in the SCSI's breakdown is its assumed 15% hurdle, not what a builder would make at today's prices.

One building. The 2025 rules were costed on one 48-home scheme in south Dublin, redrawn rather than designed fresh.

A professional body's costing. Tier 2: published by the Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland, not the State.

Levies are often waived. Both SCSI reports note temporary waivers of planning levies and water connection charges, and include the charges anyway.

Sources, in full
  1. Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland, The Real Costs of New Apartment Delivery 2025, Figure 3, Part II (Tables 9-10) and Appendix — scsi.ie
  2. Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland, The Real Cost of New Housing Delivery 2023, Tables 1-4 and regional breakdowns.
  3. Department of Housing, Planning Design Standards for Apartments: Guidelines for Planning Authorities, July 2025: section 2.2, SPPRs 2, 3 and 5, section 4.6.
What changed on this page
Published.
What this page is still waiting on

What does each apartment standard add to the cost of a home, nationally?

One building has been costed. When the State publishes a costing for its standards, it goes here.

Send it to hello.nospam@onpaper.invalid.ie.

Draft notes