On Paper✳

About On Paper

Your voice — 60 words, here

The interval, stated as method rather than biography. Name two of your own arrivals in Ireland and one thing, physical, that was different between them.

  • Do not explain what it means. The pieces explain.
  • This licenses the first person for the whole site.

A census is a country photographed at intervals: 2016, then 2022, and the difference between the two pictures is a finding.

This publication is run by someone who has been looking at Ireland the same way for thirty years — first-generation American, years in the States, years here, never long enough in one stretch to stop noticing. That is either a disqualification or the only qualification that matters.

Everything else here is reproducible: every number has a named table behind it and a script that pulls it. The observer is the one part you cannot run twice.

Where this publication standsnot neutrality

Three things we think, stated plainly so you can hold us to them.

A position, arrived at from the tables, and one that every piece here is a test of. If the data turns against any of these, we will say so here first.

One

The people arriving are not the cause.

Not an opinion. The counties under most housing pressure are the ones fewest people moved to. 82% of everyone on a welfare payment is an Irish national. Just over one in five construction workers is not Irish — the labour you would remove is the labour that builds the houses. Nor is the money spent on them the cause: asylum accommodation and the asylum payment together come to 2.6% of the gap between what the Irish state spends and what the average European state spends.

Two

It is a supply problem and a policy problem, and both are measurable.

Ireland built 4,575 homes in 2013 while losing population. It spends less of its national income than any comparable country in Europe. Its water network is funded for a tenth of its own housing target. None of that is anybody's fault except the people who decided it.

Three

It is fixable, and the list is short.

This is the part that gets called naive. A state with no money and no expertise electrified the country in 1925. Councils built at 2.77 homes per thousand people in 1975. Every piece here ends with specific changes, most of them publications of data the State already holds.

The commonest thing said about Irish housing is that it is intractable. That is a claim about the world, it is checkable, and on the evidence here it is false. Intractable problems do not have a year where the thing was done at four times the current rate.

Where it goes wrongand who it is aimed at

Too many of them, doing too little.

The instinct that distrusts the official number is a reliable instrument. It has been right about the Irish economy for a decade. Here is what happens when the same instrument gets pointed at the neighbours.

Asked what share of people living in Ireland were born abroad, the average answer in the ESRI's sample was 27.8%. The census range is 18.8–21.7%. People who were further out were significantly more likely to feel negatively about immigration.

What people estimate, and what the statistics say

Five questions put to 1,200 adults. The error runs one way on the first two and the other way on the last three.

How to read thisEach row is one question. The left chip is what people guessed on average, the right chip is the measured figure, and the line between them is the size of the error.

Public estimateActualShare of people in Irelandwho were born abroadactual range 18.8–21.7%27.8%20.3%Born outside the EU, UKor North Americaactual range 7.0–9.2%13.5%8.1%Foreign-born adultswho are in workthe gap now runs the other way51.5%76.8%Foreign-born adults witha third-level qualification34.4%58.5%Non-EU arrivals who camehere for work or study19.2%46.0%
estimate too highestimate too low
Public estimateActual

Share of people in Ireland who were born abroad

27.8%→20.3%

actual range 18.8–21.7%

Born outside the EU, UK or North America

13.5%→8.1%

actual range 7.0–9.2%

Foreign-born adults who are in work

51.5%→76.8%

the gap now runs the other way

Foreign-born adults with a third-level qualification

34.4%→58.5%

Non-EU arrivals who came here for work or study

19.2%→46.0%

estimate too highestimate too low

ESRI Research Series 225, The Role of Misperceptions in Attitudes to Immigration, January 2026. Survey of 1,200 adults, fieldwork May–June 2025. Full method and definitions at the foot of this page.

In 2025 the ESRI asked 1,200 adults in Ireland to estimate some basic facts about the people who had moved here. The answers were wrong in a pattern — not scattered, not random. Overestimate the number. Underestimate the work.

The ESRI's own headline is the one that matters: people holding more inaccurate beliefs were significantly more likely to feel negatively about immigration. The size of the error predicts the temperature of the opinion.

That is not a claim that people are stupid. Nobody carries census tables around. It is a claim about supply — of information, this time.

A real grievance left without an accurate explanation is an opening.

None of this makes anybody's rent cheaper, and none of it makes the anger manufactured. People are not being tricked into noticing that they cannot afford to live where they grew up.

What a publication can usefully do is close the gap the grievance is sitting in: put a better, checkable explanation within reach of someone looking for one.

Piece 05 counts what has been happening in that gap →

What Ireland does not know about itselfnine so far

Nine numbers the State does not have.

Every one of these came up because we went looking for a figure and there was not one. When one is answered — by a department, by an FOI, or by a reader — it comes off this list and the piece that needed it gets updated.

HousingHow many homes are currently blocked by water or wastewater capacity?No published figure. Not in the Uisce Éireann plan, the Department outputs or the planning statistics.
WelfareHow many people are living in Ireland without immigration status?No official estimate. Two published figures disagree by a factor of five.
WelfareHow many of the 20,336 work permissions granted in 2025 became jobs?Justice says the statistic is not available. Social Protection holds no linking data.
WelfareWhat share of social housing actually goes to whom?Only unmet need is published. Tenancies by nationality are not.
PrecedentHow many local authority homes were completed each year before 2005?No consistent public series. FOI lodged with the Housing Agency.
MoneyWhat does European state spending look like once you allow for how old each country's population is?Not found at Eurostat, the OECD or the ESRI. It is the best objection to the piece and we cannot answer it.
HousingWhat does the full stack of planning requirements cost, cumulatively?Never costed. Each condition is defended individually; the total has never had to be.
SentimentHow many arson attacks on asylum accommodation have there been?No official tally. The only counts are kept by a charity and a television programme.
ComingWhich towns with IPAS contracts have GP capacity, and which do not?The two datasets have never been joined. We are building it.

This is the most useful thing on the site and it is the part we did least work for. Nine specific questions about Ireland that cannot currently be answered from published data, discovered as a by-product of five pieces. Several of them are the next pieces.

How we work

And how to catch us out.

Five rules. The third one is the reason the fourth is possible.

R.1
Every number has a table behind itNamed dataset, named year, pulled by a script anyone can run.
R.2
The strongest objection goes in the pieceIf the best counter-argument only appears in the comments, the piece was propaganda.
R.3
Corrections are printed, not edited awayThe wrong version stays visible with a line through it.
R.4
No villain where a mechanism will doIncentives explain more behaviour than malice, and can actually be changed.
R.5
Nothing is inventedNo illustrative figures, no representative composites, no rounded-up quotes. Where a quotation could not be verified twice against its source, it is not printed at all.

Working with us

Send us something.

Three of the corrections on the front page were found by readers. This publication is built to be argued with, and the argument is the product.

Three things worth more than a compliment
A number we are missingAnything on the ledger above. One county is enough to start — we do not need the national figure to begin.
A correctionA figure that is wrong, a table that has been superseded, a definition we have used loosely. It gets printed at the top of this page with the wrong version struck through, and it stays there.
A question we should be askingPreferably one where you already suspect the answer is uncomfortable for a position we have taken.
hello.nospam@onpaper.invalid.ie — one address, read by a person. A correction gets printed at the top of this page with the wrong version struck through, usually the same day. Say if you would rather not be credited and you will not be; the correction still runs.
Draft notes